Wicked Good Pizza

Reviews

• Michele L.

  star star star star star 27 September 2026

  Dined at restaurant for the first time. I ordered a steak sub and opted for provolone cheese in lieu of the melted cheddar cheese. It was delicious !!! Made with actual steak and not chopped up steak ins meat. The fries were served hot and seasoned well. They hand you a buzzer to let you know when your food is ready but the waitress brought our food out to the table where we were seated . Excellent customer service . You definitely have to eat here if you can take a break from gambling as it is located in the rear of the casino

• Cynthia N.

  star star star star_border star_border 10 September 2026

  Decent pizza. Good to grab a quick bite at.  Plenty of seating inside and outside. Connected to Yellow Brick Road Casino. Their selection of single slice pizza is small, but decent: garlic broccoli, cheese, mushroom, sausage, and pepperoni. There are more specialty pizza options if you order the whole pizza.
  
  Nothing spectacular or Wizard of Oz themed here, other than the name of the restaurant.

• Brett M.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 10 September 2026

  It was one of those nights.  I got home from work and knew I wasn't in the mood to cook.  Having recently moved to the area, I decided to run down to Wicked Good Pizza for a couple slices.  I had visited here once before and dined in, ordering a pizza, some wings, and an antipasto.  On that night 2 years ago, the pizza was excellent, but slightly overpriced.  Considering this was inside a casino, I knew what I was getting myself into and looked forward to my next visit.  
  
  Fast forward to the aforementioned evening where I was in the mood for a couple slices.  When I walked in, I was informed that the special that night was buffalo wing pizza and that they also had cheese and pepperoni slices available.  I decided to be boring and grab 2 slices of cheese.  Eagerly anticipating some thin sliced goodness when I got home, I was extremely disappointed to find a greasy mess.  The cheese was pretty rubbery and the crust was not how I remembered.  Like most people, I don't struggle to put down 2 slices of cheese pizza, but for the first time in recent memory, one of the slices found the bottom of the trash bin.
  
  I was really torn about giving Wicked Good 2 stars as I quite enjoyed our meal 2 years ago, but this most recent experience was awful.  I am wiling to order a fresh pie and see if that makes a difference, but it isn't at the top of list.  If you are at the Casino and enjoying a few drinks, Wicked Pizza will soak up the booze...otherwise there are better options in Fayetteville 10 minutes up the road.

• Natalie W.

  star star star star star_border 4 September 2026

  My husband and I regularly pick up pizza from Wicked Good, and while it isn't necessarily the most gourmet pizza you'll ever eat, the slices are huge and the price is definitely right. Also, if you're sticking around inside the restaurant to eat your slice, the whole place is super well-furnished, comfortable, and inviting.

• Christopher R.

  star star star star star_border 2 September 2026

  There pizza is very good especially the sausage ! We also Love there everything wings